Pennsylvania · Medical malpractice law

Pennsylvania medical malpractice law, in plain English

A medical negligence claim in Pennsylvania runs on a clock and on the chart. The clock is two years for most claims (opens in a new tab); the chart is the record a provider must give you within 30 days of a written request (opens in a new tab); and once a complaint is filed, a licensed professional's written statement has to stand behind it within sixty days (opens in a new tab). This page sets out each rule with its source.

The short answer

How does a medical malpractice claim work in Pennsylvania?

One claim, four stretches

Line weight to scale30 days2 years

42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2) · Pa.R.C.P. 1042.3(a)

  1. The care

    Surgery, a test, a diagnosis or a prescription

    In the chartEvery order, note, result and medication is charted with its time.
  2. Your records

    You ask for the chart, in writing

    30 daysThe provider has 30 days to act on your written request, with one 30-day extension allowed.
  3. Filing

    The deadline for most claims

    2 yearsMost claims must be filed within two years.

    Your claim Filed inside the two years. The certificate of merit follows within 60 days.

  4. Certificate of merit

    After the complaint is filed

    60 daysA certificate that a licensed professional has given a written statement supporting the claim is due within 60 days of filing.
  5. Review and trial

    The case goes forward

01

How long do you have?

Pennsylvania sets a two-year limitation for an action to recover damages for injuries to the person or for the death of an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect or unlawful violence or negligence of another (opens in a new tab). A claim over medical care is such an action, so for most patients the lawsuit must be started within two years.

When the two years begin is the harder question, and the Supreme Court has answered it with an inquiry-notice rule. The discovery rule tolls the statute where the plaintiff is reasonably unaware that he has been injured and that his injury has been caused by another party’s conduct (opens in a new tab); the period starts on actual or constructive knowledge of at least some form of significant harm and of a factual cause linked to another’s conduct, without the necessity of notice of the full extent of the injury, the fact of actual negligence, or precise cause (opens in a new tab). Whether a patient used reasonable diligence is one of fact for a jury to decide (opens in a new tab). Count from the earliest date you could have known something was wrong, until a lawyer has read your dates.

There is no outer limit on top of that. The MCARE Act’s seven-year statute of repose was held unconstitutional in 2019, and the Supreme Court has since said that the General Assembly has yet to enact a substitute provision, so there remains no statutory limit of any kind upon delayed suits (opens in a new tab).

A child’s claim is counted differently. By statute, when the person entitled to bring the claim is an unemancipated minor when the cause of action accrues, the period of minority is not counted as part of the time within which the action must be commenced, and the person has the same time to start an action after reaching majority as anyone else (opens in a new tab). The page on a child’s claim takes it from there.

02

What is the certificate of merit?

Pennsylvania’s Rules of Civil Procedure add a step that most other claims do not have. In an action against a licensed professional based on an allegation that the professional deviated from an acceptable professional standard, the plaintiff’s attorney must file a certificate of merit with the complaint or within sixty days after the filing of the complaint (opens in a new tab), and the court upon good cause shown shall extend the time for filing a certificate of merit for a period not to exceed sixty days (opens in a new tab).

The certificate states one of three things. The usual one is that an appropriate licensed professional has supplied a written statement that there exists a reasonable probability that the care, skill or knowledge exercised or exhibited in the treatment, practice or work that is the subject of the complaint fell outside acceptable professional standards and that such conduct was a cause in bringing about the harm (opens in a new tab). The rule also provides for a claim that a licensed professional is responsible for others, and for a claim where expert testimony is not needed.

That is why a Pennsylvania malpractice case is reviewed before it is filed rather than after. The chart goes to a professional in the right field, and the claim goes forward only if that review supports it.

03

Who can say the care fell short?

The MCARE Act decides who may testify to a physician’s standard of care. The expert must be substantially familiar with the applicable standard of care for the specific care at issue as of the time of the alleged breach (opens in a new tab), must practice in the same subspecialty as the defendant physician or in a subspecialty which has a substantially similar standard of care for the specific care at issue (opens in a new tab), and, where the defendant physician is board certified, must be board certified by the same or a similar approved board (opens in a new tab), each subject to the exceptions the Act allows a court to make.

A surgeon’s care is read by a surgeon, an emergency physician’s by an emergency physician. Finding that person is part of the firm’s work in the first weeks of a case.

04

How do you get the chart?

You have a federal right of access to your own medical records. A covered provider must act on a request for access no later than 30 days after receipt of the request (opens in a new tab): it either gives you the records, or tells you in writing why it is denying the request. If it cannot act within the 30 days, it may take one extension of no more than 30 days (opens in a new tab), and it has to tell you in writing why and when it will respond.

Ask in writing for the complete record: the orders, the nursing notes, the medication records, the test results and the times, rather than the discharge summary alone. The gaps between what was ordered, what was done and when it was read are often where a case starts.

The Act sets the duty and its limits. Except in emergencies, a physician owes a duty to a patient to obtain the informed consent of the patient or the patient’s authorized representative prior to conducting the following procedures (opens in a new tab): surgery and its anesthesia, radiation or chemotherapy, a blood transfusion, a surgical device or appliance, and experimental treatment. Consent is informed if the patient or the patient’s authorized representative has been given a description of a procedure and the risks and alternatives that a reasonably prudent patient would require to make an informed decision as to that procedure (opens in a new tab).

A consent form with a signature on it is where that question starts, not where it ends: what was described, and what a reasonably prudent patient would have needed to hear, is decided from the record and the testimony.

06

What if the patient is partly at fault?

Pennsylvania counts a plaintiff’s own negligence against the recovery without ending the claim. In an action to recover damages for negligence resulting in death or injury, the fact that the plaintiff may have been guilty of contributory negligence does not bar a recovery where that negligence was not greater than the causal negligence of the defendants against whom recovery is sought, but the damages are diminished in proportion to the amount of negligence attributed to the plaintiff (opens in a new tab).

Among defendants, each generally pays its own share: a defendant’s liability shall be several and not joint (opens in a new tab), except in the cases the statute lists, among them where the defendant has been held liable for not less than 60% of the total liability apportioned to all parties (opens in a new tab).

A patient who missed an appointment, or did not take a medication as directed, may hear that argument from a hospital’s insurer. Whether it applies, and what it is worth, depends on what the chart shows.

07

What can be recovered?

Pennsylvania’s Constitution speaks to damages for injury directly. Outside workers’ compensation, in no other cases shall the General Assembly limit the amount to be recovered for injuries resulting in death, or for injuries to persons or property (opens in a new tab), and in case of death from such injuries, the right of action shall survive (opens in a new tab). What a claim recovers for medical costs, lost earnings and the harm to the person is set by its facts.

Punitive damages are the exception, and the MCARE Act limits them. A showing of gross negligence is insufficient to support an award of punitive damages (opens in a new tab); except in cases alleging intentional misconduct, punitive damages against an individual physician shall not exceed 200% of the compensatory damages awarded (opens in a new tab); and of any punitive award, 75% shall be paid to the prevailing party and 25% shall be paid to the Medical Care Availability and Reduction of Error Fund (opens in a new tab).

The Act also sets how future care is paid. Future damages for medical and other related expenses shall be paid as periodic payments after payment of the proportionate share of counsel fees and costs based upon the present value of the future damages awarded (opens in a new tab), unless the claimant objects and stipulates that the total amount of the future damages for medical and other related expenses, without reduction to present value, does not exceed one hundred thousand dollars (opens in a new tab). Lost earnings and the harm itself are paid as a sum.

08

Where is the case filed?

Until 2023 a medical professional liability action had a venue rule of its own. By order of August 25, 2022, effective January 1, 2023, the Supreme Court rescinded Rule 1006(a.1), the special venue rule that applied to medical professional liability actions (opens in a new tab), returning medical professionals to the same venue rules applicable to other non-governmental defendants (opens in a new tab). The order is in the Pennsylvania Bulletin (opens in a new tab).

Under those rules an action against an individual may be brought in a county where the individual may be served, the cause of action arose, or a transaction or occurrence took place out of which the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab), and an action against a corporation or similar entity, which is what a hospital is, in a county where its registered office or principal place of business is located, where it regularly conducts business, where the cause of action arose, or where a transaction or occurrence took place out of which the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab). The page on Philadelphia’s courts covers the court itself.

09

When someone has died

Two claims follow a death from medical care. A wrongful death action exists only for the benefit of the spouse, children or parents of the deceased (opens in a new tab), for what they have lost. A survival action is the person’s own claim, continued: all causes of action or proceedings, real or personal, shall survive the death of the plaintiff or of the defendant (opens in a new tab).

The MCARE Act sets their clock. A claim under the death or survival statutes must be commenced within two years after the death in the absence of affirmative misrepresentation or fraudulent concealment of the cause of death (opens in a new tab). Who may bring each claim, and for whom, is decided from the family and the estate, and is one of the first questions the firm asks.

Frequently asked questions

Does the two-year clock run from the day of the treatment?

Often, though not always. The statute sets two years for an action to recover damages for injuries caused by the negligence of another (opens in a new tab); the Supreme Court starts the period on actual or constructive knowledge of at least some form of significant harm and of a factual cause linked to another’s conduct (opens in a new tab), whether or not the patient yet knew of any negligence. Count from the earliest possible date until a lawyer tells you otherwise.

Is there a seven-year limit on Pennsylvania malpractice claims?

Not any more. The MCARE Act’s seven-year statute of repose was held unconstitutional in 2019, and the Supreme Court has said that there remains no statutory limit of any kind upon delayed suits (opens in a new tab). The two-year limitation, and when it starts, still governs.

Is a certificate of merit needed against a hospital, or only against a doctor?

The rule covers an action based on an allegation that a licensed professional deviated from an acceptable professional standard (opens in a new tab), and it provides separately for a claim that a licensed professional is responsible for others (opens in a new tab), so a claim against a hospital over its staff’s care can need one too.

Can a hospital charge for my records?

A provider may charge a reasonable, cost-based fee for a copy, and the federal rule says what the fee may include. The timing is fixed: the provider must act on the request no later than 30 days after receiving it (opens in a new tab).

Are damages capped in Pennsylvania?

The Constitution says the General Assembly may not limit the amount to be recovered for injuries resulting in death, or for injuries to persons or property (opens in a new tab). The one limit is on punitive damages against an individual physician, which the MCARE Act holds to 200% of the compensatory damages awarded (opens in a new tab) except for intentional misconduct.

What if the hospital says I was partly to blame?

Pennsylvania does not end a claim for that. The recovery is diminished in proportion to the negligence attributed to the plaintiff, and barred only where the plaintiff’s negligence was greater than the defendants’ (opens in a new tab).

Medical malpractice claims in Philadelphia, by who provided the care

  1. 01

    Philadelphia courts

    The court, the county the rules allow, the certificate of merit, and the court’s medical malpractice program.

    Explore Philadelphia courts 
  2. 02

    Federal and VA care

    The written claim to the agency within two years, the sum it must state, the wait, and what the United States pays.

    Explore federal and VA care 
  3. 03

    Emergency room care

    The screening and stabilization the law requires, when a hospital answers for a contract doctor, and the clock.

    Explore emergency room care 
  4. 04

    A child’s claim

    The years of minority are not counted, a guardian brings the claim, the court approves a settlement, and future care is paid over time.

    Explore a child’s claim 

Last stop

Talk to a Philadelphia medical malpractice lawyer today.

Call 215.515.8143

Answered 24 hours a day · No fee unless we win

Free case evaluation