Philadelphia · Federal and VA care

Care at the VA or a federal health center in Philadelphia: the claim goes to the agency first

The Department of Veterans Affairs runs the Corporal Michael J. Crescenz VA Medical Center on Woodland Avenue (opens in a new tab) and its clinics around Philadelphia. A claim over care there is a claim against the United States, and it has to be presented in writing to the appropriate federal agency within two years (opens in a new tab) before any court sees it. This page sets out the steps.

01

Where is federal care given in Philadelphia?

The VA Philadelphia health care system’s own site names the Corporal Michael J. Crescenz Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center at 3900 Woodland Avenue (opens in a new tab) and lists its outpatient clinics in the region (opens in a new tab). A veteran treated there, or at one of those clinics, was treated by employees of the United States.

A second kind of federal provider is less obvious: a community health center. When the Health Resources and Services Administration deems a center, its officers and its physicians and other practitioners shall be deemed to be an employee of the Public Health Service for a calendar year (opens in a new tab), and a negligence claim against them is a claim against the United States. HRSA publishes a search tool for the centers it has deemed (opens in a new tab), year by year. Whether a particular clinic’s staff were deemed in the year of the care is checked there, never assumed from the name on the door.

03

What is different about what can be recovered?

The measure of fault is Pennsylvania’s. The United States answers in accordance with the law of the place where the act or omission occurred (opens in a new tab), so what counts as negligent care, and what a patient’s own fault does to a claim, are decided as they would be against a private hospital in Philadelphia.

Two things are different. The United States is liable in the same manner and to the same extent as a private individual under like circumstances, but shall not be liable for interest prior to judgment or for punitive damages (opens in a new tab). And the sum in the written claim caps the lawsuit, as above, so the claim has to be valued carefully before it is presented.

04

Which deadline applies, the federal one or Pennsylvania’s?

The federal one governs a claim against the United States: the written claim must be received by the agency within two years after such claim accrues (opens in a new tab). Pennsylvania’s own two years, for an action to recover damages for injuries to the person caused by the negligence of another (opens in a new tab), governs a claim against a private provider who treated the same patient.

One stay in a hospital can involve both. A veteran transferred from the VA to a private hospital, or treated at a private hospital under a VA arrangement, may have a claim on each side of that line, each on its own clock and its own procedure. The chart from each provider is where that is worked out.

Frequently asked questions

Can I sue the VA?

The claim is against the United States, and it starts with the agency: a tort claim shall be forever barred unless it is presented in writing to the appropriate federal agency within two years after such claim accrues (opens in a new tab). A lawsuit follows only after the agency denies the claim in writing, or after six months without a decision.

How much do I ask for in the claim?

A specific sum. The agency must receive a claim for money damages in a sum certain (opens in a new tab), and a later lawsuit shall not be instituted for any sum in excess of the amount of the claim presented (opens in a new tab), except on newly discovered evidence or intervening facts. The figure is set with a lawyer before the claim goes in.

Is a neighborhood health center a federal provider?

Only in a year it was deemed. A center’s practitioners shall be deemed to be an employee of the Public Health Service for a calendar year (opens in a new tab) that HRSA has approved, and HRSA’s search tool (opens in a new tab) shows which centers and which years. The answer changes which deadline and which procedure apply.

Does Pennsylvania law still matter in a VA case?

Yes. The United States is liable in accordance with the law of the place where the act or omission occurred (opens in a new tab), so Pennsylvania decides what was negligent and what the harm is worth. The federal differences are the agency claim, the sum certain, and that the United States shall not be liable for punitive damages (opens in a new tab).

Keep reading

  1. 01

    Pennsylvania law

    The two-year clock and when it starts, the certificate of merit, the expert, your records, a patient’s own fault, damages, venue and death cases.

    Pennsylvania law page 
  2. 02

    Philadelphia courts

    The court, the county the rules allow, the certificate of merit, and the court’s medical malpractice program.

    Explore Philadelphia courts 
  3. 03

    Emergency room care

    The screening and stabilization the law requires, when a hospital answers for a contract doctor, and the clock.

    Explore emergency room care 
  4. 04

    A child’s claim

    The years of minority are not counted, a guardian brings the claim, the court approves a settlement, and future care is paid over time.

    Explore a child’s claim 

Last stop

Talk to a Philadelphia medical malpractice lawyer today.

Call 215.515.8143

Answered 24 hours a day · No fee unless we win

Free case evaluation