Philadelphia · Emergency room care
Emergency room care in Philadelphia: what the hospital owed you, and who answers
An emergency department owes everyone who comes in an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department (opens in a new tab), and anyone with an emergency condition such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab). This page sets out that duty, who answers for the care, and the clock.
The short answer
What does a Philadelphia emergency room owe a patient under the law?
Two things, by federal statute. When a person comes to the emergency department and asks for examination or treatment, the hospital must provide for an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department (opens in a new tab) to find out whether an emergency medical condition exists, and if one does, such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab) before any transfer. Whether the care that followed met the standard of care is a separate question, answered from the chart under Pennsylvania law.
What does federal law require of an emergency department?
The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act applies to every hospital with an emergency department that takes Medicare. When any individual comes to the emergency department and a request is made for examination or treatment, the hospital must provide for an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department, including ancillary services routinely available to the emergency department (opens in a new tab). If an emergency medical condition is found, the hospital must provide such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab), or transfer the patient under the statute’s conditions.
The statute gives the patient a claim of its own. Any individual who suffers personal harm as a direct result of a participating hospital’s violation of a requirement of this section may, in a civil action against the participating hospital, obtain those damages available for personal injury under the law of the State in which the hospital is located (opens in a new tab). That action has its own limit: no action may be brought under this paragraph more than two years after the date of the violation (opens in a new tab).
Who answers for the emergency doctor?
Often the doctor who treated you in the emergency room was not the hospital’s employee. Pennsylvania’s MCARE Act says when the hospital answers anyway. A hospital may be held vicariously liable for the acts of another health care provider through principles of ostensible agency only if the evidence shows that a reasonably prudent person in the patient’s position would be justified in the belief that the care in question was being rendered by the hospital or its agents, or the care in question was advertised or otherwise represented to the patient as care being rendered by the hospital or its agents (opens in a new tab).
A doctor’s privileges are not enough by themselves: evidence that a physician holds staff privileges at a hospital shall be insufficient to establish vicarious liability through principles of ostensible agency (opens in a new tab) unless one of those two showings is made. What the patient was told, what was on the signs and the forms, and who billed for the visit all matter.
What does the emergency room chart show?
An emergency record is built on times: triage, the first physician contact, each order, each result and when it was read, the medications and the discharge. You have a right to it. A provider must act on a request for access no later than 30 days after receipt of the request (opens in a new tab), with one extension of no more than 30 days (opens in a new tab) if it tells you why in writing.
The gaps are often the case: a result posted and not read, a reassessment ordered and not done, a discharge before a test came back. Ask for the complete record, including the nursing notes and the test results rather than the discharge paperwork alone.
How long does an emergency room patient have?
Two years for most claims, the limitation for an action to recover damages for injuries to the person or for the death of an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect or unlawful violence or negligence of another (opens in a new tab). The federal claim over the screening and stabilization duties has its own two years after the date of the violation (opens in a new tab).
A malpractice claim also needs its certificate of merit with the complaint or within sixty days after the filing of the complaint (opens in a new tab), stating that an appropriate licensed professional has given a written statement supporting the claim. In an emergency case that professional is one who practices emergency medicine, and the review of the chart is where the firm starts.
One more rule of the Act is written for emergencies. The physician’s duty to obtain informed consent before surgery, radiation, a transfusion, a surgical device or an experimental treatment begins with the words Except in emergencies (opens in a new tab), so a claim about an emergency procedure is about the care itself, not the consent.
Frequently asked questions
The emergency room sent me home and I got worse. Is that a case?
It may be two questions. Whether the hospital gave an appropriate medical screening examination (opens in a new tab) and stabilizing treatment is the federal one; whether the care met the standard of care is the Pennsylvania one, answered from the chart by a professional in emergency medicine. Both start with the complete record of the visit.
The doctor who treated me was not a hospital employee. Can the hospital still be responsible?
Only through the Act’s ostensible agency rule: where a reasonably prudent person in the patient’s position would be justified in the belief that the care in question was being rendered by the hospital or its agents (opens in a new tab), or the care was advertised or otherwise represented to the patient as care being rendered by the hospital or its agents (opens in a new tab). Staff privileges alone shall be insufficient (opens in a new tab).
How long do I have?
Two years, for most claims, under Pennsylvania’s limitation for injuries to the person caused by the negligence of another (opens in a new tab); the federal screening-and-stabilization claim has its own limit of two years after the date of the violation (opens in a new tab). When a period starts can depend on what you could have known, so count from the visit until a lawyer tells you otherwise.
Did they need my consent in the emergency room?
The Act’s consent duty for surgery and the other listed procedures applies except in emergencies (opens in a new tab). What a claim about emergency treatment turns on is whether the care met the standard, which the chart and a qualified professional decide.
Keep reading
- 01
Pennsylvania law
The two-year clock and when it starts, the certificate of merit, the expert, your records, a patient’s own fault, damages, venue and death cases.
Pennsylvania law page - 02
Philadelphia courts
The court, the county the rules allow, the certificate of merit, and the court’s medical malpractice program.
Explore Philadelphia courts - 03
Federal and VA care
The written claim to the agency within two years, the sum it must state, the wait, and what the United States pays.
Explore federal and VA care - 04
A child’s claim
The years of minority are not counted, a guardian brings the claim, the court approves a settlement, and future care is paid over time.
Explore a child’s claim
Last stop