Philadelphia · The courts
Where a Philadelphia medical malpractice case is filed, and what the court expects
Philadelphia is a judicial district of its own, and its Court of Common Pleas assigns medical malpractice cases to its Major Jury Program (opens in a new tab). Since 2023 those cases follow the same venue rules as any other (opens in a new tab). This page sets out the court, the county and what the court asks of a medical case.
The short answer
Where is a Philadelphia medical malpractice case filed?
In the Court of Common Pleas of the First Judicial District, which the statute defines as the City and County of Philadelphia (opens in a new tab), where medical malpractice cases are assigned to the court’s Major Jury Program (opens in a new tab). Which county is proper follows the general rules: an action against an individual may be brought where the individual may be served, where the cause of action arose, or where a transaction or occurrence took place out of which the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab), and an action against a corporation where its registered office or principal place of business is, where it regularly conducts business, or where the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab).
Which court hears the case?
Pennsylvania divides itself into sixty judicial districts, and the first is the City and County of Philadelphia (opens in a new tab). Its trial court is the Court of Common Pleas, whose Trial Division sits in City Hall (opens in a new tab).
The Trial Division’s civil side posts the case management protocols for the medical malpractice cases assigned to the Court’s Major Jury Program (opens in a new tab), and says counsel in those cases has a continuing obligation to comply with every published protocol. A case here runs on the court’s schedule from the day it is filed.
Which county can the case be brought in?
For twenty years a medical professional liability action had a venue rule of its own. By order of August 25, 2022, effective January 1, 2023, the Supreme Court rescinded Rule 1006(a.1), the special venue rule that applied to medical professional liability actions (opens in a new tab), so that medical professionals are governed by the same venue rules applicable to other non-governmental defendants (opens in a new tab). The order itself is in the Pennsylvania Bulletin (opens in a new tab).
Those rules say where a case may be brought. Against an individual, in a county where the individual may be served, the cause of action arose, or a transaction or occurrence took place out of which the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab). Against a hospital or a practice group, which is a corporation or a similar entity, in a county where its registered office or principal place of business is located, where it regularly conducts business, where the cause of action arose, or where a transaction or occurrence took place out of which the cause of action arose (opens in a new tab).
Where more than one defendant is answerable together, the action may be brought against all defendants in any county in which venue may be laid against any one of them (opens in a new tab). A court may still move a case: for the convenience of parties and witnesses, on petition of any party, to another county where the action could originally have been brought (opens in a new tab).
What does the court require of a medical case?
A certificate of merit. In an action based on an allegation that a licensed professional deviated from an acceptable professional standard, the plaintiff’s attorney must file one with the complaint or within sixty days after the filing of the complaint (opens in a new tab), and the court on good cause shown shall extend the time for a period not to exceed sixty days (opens in a new tab).
A qualified expert. Under the MCARE Act, an expert who testifies to a physician’s standard of care must practice in the same subspecialty as the defendant physician or in a subspecialty which has a substantially similar standard of care for the specific care at issue (opens in a new tab), and, where the defendant is board certified, be board certified by the same or a similar approved board (opens in a new tab), subject to the exceptions the Act sets out.
The review of the chart comes before all of this. The professional who reviews it has to be the right one for the care in question, and the firm’s first weeks on a case are spent getting the record complete and in front of that person.
How long does a Philadelphia patient have?
Two years, for most claims: the limitation for an action to recover damages for injuries to the person or for the death of an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect or unlawful violence or negligence of another (opens in a new tab). Where the claim is a death or survival action over medical care, the MCARE Act says it must be commenced within two years after the death in the absence of affirmative misrepresentation or fraudulent concealment of the cause of death (opens in a new tab).
When the two years begin can depend on what the patient could have known. The Supreme Court applies an inquiry-notice rule, tied to actual or constructive knowledge of at least some form of significant harm and of a factual cause linked to another’s conduct, without the necessity of notice of the full extent of the injury, the fact of actual negligence, or precise cause (opens in a new tab), and whether a patient used reasonable diligence is one of fact for a jury to decide (opens in a new tab).
There is no longer an outer limit on top of that. The Act’s seven-year statute of repose was held unconstitutional in 2019, and the Supreme Court has since said that the General Assembly has yet to enact a substitute provision, so there remains no statutory limit of any kind upon delayed suits (opens in a new tab).
Frequently asked questions
Does the case have to be filed in the county where the treatment happened?
Not any more. The rule that required it was rescinded effective January 1, 2023 (opens in a new tab). A case may be brought in any county the general rules allow, including, against a hospital or a practice, a county where it regularly conducts business (opens in a new tab).
Can the hospital move the case out of Philadelphia?
It can ask. A court may transfer an action for the convenience of parties and witnesses, on petition of any party, to another county where the action could originally have been brought (opens in a new tab), or where it finds a fair and impartial trial cannot be held in the county (opens in a new tab). Whether a petition succeeds depends on the facts of the case.
What is the Major Jury Program?
The Court of Common Pleas’ own term for the track its medical malpractice cases run on. The court posts the case management protocols for the medical malpractice cases assigned to the Court’s Major Jury Program (opens in a new tab) and revises them from time to time.
Is there a deadline I could miss before I even know I was hurt?
Pennsylvania no longer has one for medical care. The seven-year outer limit was struck down in 2019, and the Supreme Court has said there remains no statutory limit of any kind upon delayed suits (opens in a new tab). The two-year period still runs from when a patient knew or should have known of some form of significant harm and of a factual cause linked to another’s conduct (opens in a new tab), so the earliest date you could have known matters.
Keep reading
- 01
Pennsylvania law
The two-year clock and when it starts, the certificate of merit, the expert, your records, a patient’s own fault, damages, venue and death cases.
Pennsylvania law page - 02
Federal and VA care
The written claim to the agency within two years, the sum it must state, the wait, and what the United States pays.
Explore federal and VA care - 03
Emergency room care
The screening and stabilization the law requires, when a hospital answers for a contract doctor, and the clock.
Explore emergency room care - 04
A child’s claim
The years of minority are not counted, a guardian brings the claim, the court approves a settlement, and future care is paid over time.
Explore a child’s claim
Last stop